I’m rarely asked what I’ve learned in nearly sixteen years of ordained ministry. So what a blessed day it was when, while on a walk, my brother-in-law asked just this question. “And if you could,” he added, “try to explain it in terms a non-church-going geologist could understand.” (As an employee of the US Geological Survey, I suppose these are the people among whom he spends the most time.)
So here is what I told him:
- There is always more to the story. No matter what the person before me is confessing, reveling in, or complaining about, there is more. Not necessarily another side to the story. Just always… more.
- You cannot make anyone do anything they don’t want to do.
- God is so strange. Always present and always faithful. But often in a really strange way.
Of course, I’ve learned other things as well. In a sermon, try to make your point and land the plane without rambling on and on. Major plumbing repairs cost an awful lot, but are definitely worth it. Money generally follows mission. And, a lesson from years of street ministry – never give cash assistance lest you turn into a human ATM.
When I started at my current parish, an urban congregation located right smack in the middle of Honolulu’s affordable housing crisis, I realized right away that a lot of my job was going to be calming the waters of chaos. There is a “just show up” culture in Hawai‘i that is wonderful and keeps our parish constantly lively. That same culture, plus an abundance of need—unhoused people needing to use the bathroom, requests for help with rent payments, building usage inquiries—creates a constant swirl of commotion that makes it difficult to get anything done.
The other day, I’m sitting in my office when the parish door swings open. It’s Thee, a chronically unhoused woman with a way of talking that makes a lot of sense to her, but is mostly unintelligible to me. Thee does not like me, and perhaps my lack of understanding is partly why. Typically, she shrugs me off and heads straight for Bill, our parish administrator.
Bill has been at Saint Elizabeth’s for six years and knows many of our neighbors very well. I also blame Bill, to some extent, for the waters of chaos. Bill is good at helping people, likes chaos and, in my mind, sometimes accommodates it too much.
But Thee has decided it’s a good day to take a risk on me. Or test me. She does a sassy lean against my door frame and demands, “Hey, can I borrow twenty dollars?”
Great! An opportunity to create a new rule.
“No, I’m sorry. We can’t give cash out here.”
It is the wrong answer, obviously. Thee turns around, to Bill’s office. “Hey, can I borrow twenty dollars?”
I know Bill heard my initial response. And I know that he will respect the new “no cash” boundary I’ve set out.
But instead of replying in the negative, Bill stands up. He walks over to a filing cabinet and pulls out a yellow folder. He removes a twenty dollar bill and hands it to Thee.
She is triumphant. Gleeful! “See! He did it, he gave me twenty dollars!”
“No, Thee,” Bill says. “I’m not giving you money. I’m not sure why, but you gave me that twenty last week, and I kept it for you. See? This folder has your name on it.”
The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom.
Sixteen years of ministry have taught me that boundaries are important. I still believe that. But six months in this parish are reminding me that holy chaos, room for the Spirit to work and for us all to be transformed, is absolutely necessary.
I came here with experience, and I think my experience is useful. But Bill has something I don’t: six years of knowing Thee. And Thee has something I don’t: the experience of being Thee.
Perhaps the most important thing I’ve learned in sixteen years is the first thing on my list. There is always more to the story.
The second is “like unto it”: I can’t make anyone do anything they don’t want to do.
And God, as usual, is just so strange.
The Rev. Katie Nakamura Rengers
Priest-in-Charge, Saint Elizabeth’s Honolulu
ktnakamura@gmail.com
The Rev. Katie Nakamura Rengers serves as Priest-in-Charge of Saint Elizabeth’s Episcopal Church in Honolulu. She previously planted The Abbey, a congregation in Birmingham, Alabama, and served on denominational staff resourcing and encouraging leaders as they started, nurtured, and sustained new faith communities. Katie is passionate about helping churches discover new ways to love God, serve their neighbors, and share in the life of their communities.







No Comments