In a story often cited by Howard Thurman and Martin Luther King, Jr., Frederick Douglass once addressed an antislavery meeting at the very moment when the abolitionist movement had come under unusual strain. The Fugitive Slave Act of 1850 had emboldened slave catchers, returned many escaped people to bondage, and filled abolitionists with frustration and despair.
Douglass delivered a somber assessment. He lamented that the cause of abolition seemed stalled, that the nation was complicit, and that the enslaved remained in chains despite years of moral appeal. His mood and rhetoric were bleak — he wondered aloud whether there was any hope left for justice.
It was at this point that Sojourner Truth, sitting in the audience, rose and called out to Douglass in her commanding voice: “Frederick, is God dead?”
Her words jolted the assembly, reminding everyone that despair denies the presence and promise of God. Douglass himself later recalled the moment as one that shook him out of his discouragement. The story came to symbolize the tension between prophetic realism and transcendent faith in the abolitionist movement — Douglass representing the moral clarity of reason, Truth representing the mystical, unwavering trust that God’s justice will prevail even in dark times.
For Howard Thurman, Sojourner Truth’s question was not a rebuke but a “summons back to spiritual center.” As Thurman preached in the mid-1960’s, “when all visible signs of progress fail, when the cause of justice seems lost, when even the prophets fall silent in fatigue, then faith itself must speak — not as optimism or denial, but as the stubborn fact of the spirit.”
Our daily headlines scream urgency. The human pain underneath these headlines demands our careful attention. It all has a drumbeat of finality: democracy’s last stand, the planet’s point of no return. Political apocalypticism treats each election as civilization’s final referendum. “If they win, it’s over.” Both world and church speak in ultimate terms — as if history itself is holding its breath.
What concerns me is that when we treat every moment as the last moment, we risk losing something essential.
We sacrifice wisdom for shortcuts, as if there is no time for devoting ourselves —and our congregations — to full faith development.
We burn out the faithful. You cannot maintain crisis-level intensity indefinitely. When every issue is ultimate, we exhaust the very people called to bear witness across decades.
We forget to plant trees. Perhaps the deepest cost of apocalyptic thinking is its refusal to invest in futures it cannot imagine. Why pray? Why mentor the teenager? If this is the last day, such things seem foolish. But Christian hope has always planted trees in whose shade we will never rest.
And then there is Jesus. Jesus faced Roman occupation, religious corruption, injustice, and his own execution. If anyone had reason to live apocalyptically, it was him. Yet he told parables about farmers planting for future harvests, servants preparing for uncertain returns, mustard seeds growing slowly into trees. He created a community designed to outlast his physical presence.
Jesus lived with urgency AND long-term vision. This is the fundamental tension of Christian hope. It is a tension I believe we need to accept anew, even as we risk being misunderstood — from left or right — for not being “urgent enough.” The urgency of today’s work exists because of tomorrow’s promise, not despite it. This is durable hope. It takes the present seriously without collapsing the future into it.
What might this mean for all who seek to follow Jesus?
We disciple the next generation as if they have a future. We don’t just mobilize young people for our urgent causes; we equip them with theological depth and wisdom that will serve them across decades.
We pursue reconciliation even with opponents. If this were truly the final battle, we’d only need to win. But durable hope recognizes we’ll share neighborhoods and cities with our opponents tomorrow; hence we practice the hard work of peace today.
We maintain theological proportion. Not every challenge is THE challenge. We learn history so we can recognize that the church has survived worse — and will continue by God’s grace. This recognition doesn’t dilute resolve. It leavens our urgency with persistent grace.
But here’s the hardest part: doing all this takes longer.
Apocalyptic thinking promises quick resolution — the final battle, the ultimate victory. It’s dramatically satisfying. But Christian hope operates on God’s timeline, which often feels frustratingly slow. The mustard seed doesn’t become a tree overnight.
“Fight the ultimate battle NOW” gets more clicks than “faithfully build what your grandchildren will use.” But the latter is what most of the Christian life actually looks like. For those of us in ministry leadership, this distinction matters. We face real urgency — people in crisis, cruelties demanding response. We’re not called to passivity.
But we’re also not called to baptize every urgency as ultimate. Our calling is to help people live faithfully in the present while preparing for the future.
This means sometimes disappointing people who want us to declare their particular issue the most important fight of all time. It means resisting the constant pressure to live at apocalyptic pitch.
Jesus only went to the cross once. The incarnation wasn’t a dress rehearsal. Golgotha wasn’t practice. The resurrection didn’t need a do-over. It is the source of our durable hope in every season.
So yes — let’s engage the urgent challenges. Let’s speak prophetically to power, pursue justice for the oppressed, care for creation. These things matter intensely. But let’s do them with steady confidence that tomorrow is coming, and it will need faithful people who built wisely today.
Every day is not the last day. The urgent work of today matters precisely because, in God’s world and by God’s presence, tomorrow is coming.
Discussion Prompts:
- “Is God dead?”
Sojourner Truth’s question shook Frederick Douglass out of despair.
What would it look like for us to hear that same question today in our activism, ministry, or personal discouragement? Where do we most need to be “summoned back to spiritual center”?
- Urgency vs. Endurance
“When every issue is ultimate, we exhaust the very people called to bear witness across decades.”
How can faith communities hold both urgency and patience, responding to real crises without succumbing to perpetual crisis-mode?
- Planting for Futures We May Never See
“Christian hope has always planted trees in whose shade we will never rest.”
Where in your life or ministry are you being called to plant something that might not bear fruit in your lifetime? What practices nurture this kind of durable hope?
No Comments